View Full Version : The Semicolon


Non-Logical-Idea-Guy
11-07-07, 01:49 PM
Where and when to use a semi colon, examples please..

shorty_37
11-07-07, 01:55 PM
Shorty asked for the remote; Nietzche handed it to her.

tablariddim
11-07-07, 01:59 PM
John owns a fruit shop; his bananas are big. (instead of:John owns a fruit shop and his bananas are big.)

Spuriousmonkey writes on Sciforums; he sometimes has tantrums. (instead of: Spuriousmonkey writes on Sciforums and he sometimes has tantrums.)

A semi colon is used to separate 2 complete and related sentences; the second sentence is usually a comment on the first and is used instead of, and, but, or etc..

Non-Logical-Idea-Guy
11-07-07, 02:00 PM
so its used instead of a connective? Shorty asked for the remote and Nietzche handed it to her. OR Shorty asked for the remote; Nietzche handed it to her.

mikenostic
11-07-07, 02:10 PM
Shorty asked for the remote; Nietzche handed it to her.
http://www.accuratewriting.com/w1-8.shtml

While the colon is mostly used at the end of a salutation for a business letter or to introduce a quote, it also can be used between two independent clauses, just as a semicolon can. The big difference is that you use a colon to set up reason, evidence, or justification in the second clause. For example,

The price of gas keeps going up: it's currently $1.40 per gallon.


A colon can also be used after an independent clause to introduce a list. The words before the colon *must* be an independent clause, but the items after the colon do not. For example,

These are my favorite movies: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone, Chocolat, Gone with the Wind.

So, with the exception of the above, a colon and semicolon can be used more or less interchangeably.

tablariddim
11-07-07, 02:10 PM
Yah.

MacGyver1968
11-07-07, 02:26 PM
"Dave had a Partial Colectomy; he now has a semi-colon." :)

(was that proper use?)

mikenostic
11-07-07, 03:02 PM
My gay friend Scott likes to hang out in sentences: you can always find him next to the colon!
:roflmao:

shorty_37
11-07-07, 03:28 PM
Logic I think you should use the above 2 examples on your homework LOL

iceaura
11-07-07, 05:12 PM
So, with the exception of the above, a colon and semicolon can be used more or less interchangeably. Not really - the colon has a feel of leaning to it. What comes after a colon is not equivalent in status to what comes before it, but rather dependent for context and meaning.

A semicolon separates two basically equal-status notions. Either one would make some kind of sense, and belong there, without the other. They illuminate each other, rather than one the other. Making sense, am I?

At any rate, if you exchange them the feel and meaning changes.

Vonnegut says the only function of a semicolon is to prove the author went to college. But he used them, occasionally ;)

glaucon
11-07-07, 05:39 PM
Purchase Strunk and White's "The Elements of Style".

Once you've read this, you'll never wonder about syntax or punctuation again.

iceaura
11-07-07, 05:46 PM
Purchase Strunk and White's "The Elements of Style". The old version, from a used book store.

There's a new one out, in which someone has "improved" White's examples and prose. They deserve none of your money.

redarmy11
11-07-07, 10:46 PM
I'm never sure. I know it's sort of halfway between a comma and a fullstop, so I use it when it feels right to do so without having any set rule about it. I really should look it up;(?) as should you.

It's good for lists: "John went to the supermarket and bought some milk; 4 apples; a loaf of bread; a bag of sugar; some nipple clamps and an enormous vibrator".

But, that function aside, I remain a bit perplexed by it.

redarmy11
11-07-07, 10:57 PM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semicolon

In English, the semicolon has two main purposes:

It binds two sentences more closely than they would be if separated by a full stop/period. It often replaces a conjunction such as and or but. Writers might consider this appropriate where they are trying to indicate a close relationship between two sentences, or a 'run-on' in meaning from one to the next; they might not want the connection to be broken by the abrupt use of a full stop.
It is used as a stronger division than a comma, to make meaning clear in a sentence where commas are being used for other purposes. A common example of this use is to separate the items of a list when some of the items themselves contain commas.
There are several cases where semicolons may be used:

Use a semicolon between closely related independent clauses not joined by a coordinating conjunction: "I went to the pool; I was informed that it was closed."
Use a semicolon between independent clauses linked with a transitional phrase or conjunctive adverb: "I like to eat cows; however, they don't like to be eaten by me."
Use a semicolon between items in a series containing internal punctuation: "There are several Waffle Houses in Atlanta, Georgia; Greenville, South Carolina; Gainesville, Florida; and Mobile, Alabama."
A semicolon can be used to separate independent clauses that are joined by coordinating conjunctions when the clauses have internal commas that might lead to misreading: "After the game, I won a red beanie baby, four edible ingots, and a certificate of excellence; but when the storm came, I lost it all in a torrent of sleet, snow, and profanity."
Semicolons are always followed by a lower case letter, unless that letter begins a proper noun.

So there we; have it.

Fraggle Rocker
11-08-07, 12:25 AM
So it's used instead of a conjunction? Shorty asked for the remote and Nietzsche handed it to her. OR Shorty asked for the remote; Nietzsche handed it to her.It is often used in sentences where it's not easy to think of an appropriate conjunction.Most of the posts on SciForums are very articulate; it's my favorite BBS website.I would hesitate to use "therefore" in that sentence because this might not be the only reason it's my favorite website. This way the implication is clearer that there may other reasons.
So, with the exception of the above, a colon and semicolon can be used more or less interchangeably.Not at all. The clauses on both sides of a semicolon are coordinate, meaning neither one dominates. The clause following a colon is subordinate. In a particular case it may be possible to write the sentence either way, but it will have two somewhat different meanings.Most of the posts on SciForums are very articulate: it's my favorite website.This makes it clear that there is only one reason.

maxg
11-08-07, 08:07 AM
Personally I prefer the dash--it's the more modern version of the semi-colon.

EDIT: This is technically referred to as the M-dash or em-dash (not to be confused with the N-dash).

spuriousmonkey
11-08-07, 08:31 AM
you can't go wrong with a semi-colon; it is da shit

shorty_37
11-08-07, 08:43 AM
when in doubt use
no punctuation
at all like gustav

Fraggle Rocker
11-08-07, 09:36 AM
Personally I prefer the dash--it's the more modern version of the semi-colon. EDIT: This is technically referred to as the M-dash or em-dash (not to be confused with the N-dash).As an editor, I only allow dashes that are paired, which makes them more akin to parentheses.

One reason dashes are not more widely used is that they are not available in all computer fonts. The one used by SciForums is a good example. They just appear as two hyphens, like on an old-fashioned typewriter. Word-processing software generally converts a double hyphen to a dash, but most e-mail and BBS software does not incorporate state-of-the-art word processing.

BTW, printers refer to en-dashes and em-dashes because of the space they take up on the page. The rest of us can just call them hyphens and dashes, respectively, without risking confusion. As in your example, a dash should be flush with both words, with no intervening spaces.

BTW(2), there's no hyphen in the word semicolon, at least not in modern American dictionaries.

maxg
11-08-07, 09:49 AM
As an editor, I only allow dashes that are paired, which makes them more akin to parentheses.

I like the paired dash too, but the stand-alone dash is fine as a substitute for a semi colon & I've certainly seen in plenty of published works. (BTW, what do you edit? I've worked as an editor before although it wouldn't show here since I don't take the time to edit myself.)


One reason dashes are not more widely used is that they are not available in all computer fonts. The one used by SciForums is a good example. They just appear as two hyphens, like on an old-fashioned typewriter. Word-processing software generally converts a double hyphen to a dash, but most e-mail and BBS software does not incorporate state-of-the-art word processing.

I've got them programed in on Microsoft Word as alt-m and alt-n but they don't make it easy.


BTW, printers refer to en-dashes and em-dashes because of the space they take up on the page. The rest of us can just call them hyphens and dashes, respectively, without risking confusion. As in your example, a dash should be flush with both words, with no intervening spaces.

Since I can't type it here it is hard to show but the en-dash is bigger than a hyphen and gets used somewhat differently, so I would avoid calling it a hyphen. (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dash#En_dash)


BTW(2), there's no hyphen in the word semicolon, at least not in modern American dictionaries.

I tend to over-hyphenate.

spuriousmonkey
11-08-07, 10:23 AM
BTW(2), there's no hyphen in the word semicolon, at least not in modern American dictionaries.

there is no such thing as BTW(2) either in them; embrace the internet; or suffer

Fraggle Rocker
11-08-07, 11:53 AM
there is no such thing as BTW(2) either in them; embrace the internet; or sufferI do most of my editing work via the internet, but I don't understand what you mean at all.

maxg
11-08-07, 12:35 PM
there is no such thing as BTW(2) either in them; embrace the internet; or suffer

You are blatant in your misuse of the semi colon aren't you?

Fraggle Rocker
11-08-07, 02:34 PM
there is no such thing as BTW(2) either in them; embrace the internet; or suffer
You are blatant in your misuse of the semicolon, aren't you?The second one is certainly wrong. You could conceivably put a comma there but the sentence would be just as good without it. The first semicolon may be correct, but the clause before it just doesn't make sense. Perhaps he meant to write "in them either" and got the words mixed up. But even then it doesn't make sense in reference to my comment BTW(2), which was about the word "semicolon" having no hyphen.

Spud Emperor
11-11-07, 05:34 AM
I quite like the semicolon; a bit half-arsed though, if you ask me!

Captain Kremmen
11-11-07, 06:40 AM
I detest semicolons. And Colons. Except for lists.
If a comma won't do, then you need to put a full stop and start a new sentence.