Fraggle Rocker
Staff member
I didn't mean to imply that it was hated. Merely that it was an artificial creation, and it's not usually very easy to get people to accept something like that. After all, the whole point was to create an accent that would instantly identify members of the "upper class," as democratization and the attrition of the aristocracy made them more difficult to identify by appearance--no footmen, for example.RP was never traditionally hated. If you watch any English Film from the 1940s you will hear it spoken constantly, and with no overtones of snobbery or privilege. Cockneys (from London) and Brummies (from Birmingham) would have watched whole films with people speaking in this accent, and not remarked upon it.
However, its appearance coincided with the dawn of the Electronic Age, and every language community needs a standard dialect (or at least accent) that everyone can understand easily. In America it was developed gradually. The national network radio (and later TV) studios were in Hollywood and New York City, so the population heard announcers speaking with California and New York accents, which aren't very different. Eventually the minor differences were leveled and that became Standard American English.
In England they just took RP because it already had the advantage of being a non-regional, relatively "neutral" accent/dialect that everyone could understand without much effort. In the early days it was often called "Oxford English," especially by Americans, because it was introduced to the country by teaching it to upper-class children in their private schools, which are confusingly called "public schools" over there. But now we call it "BBC English" because it's used in all the broadcasts.
It has changed over the decades. If you listen to a speech by Queen Elizabeth early in her reign and compare it to the way she talks today, it almost sounds like a different person. We notice the difference over here; back in the 1950s I found it almost impossible to understand the dialog in a British movie. Today it's easy. Some of that is of course the result of the British Invasion in rock'n'roll, hearing the Beatles and Herman's Hermits on the radio every day, and popular TV shows like Monty Python and Upstairs Downstairs. We got used to it so it's easier to understand. But even John Cleese and Eric Idle don't talk quite the same as they did forty years ago.
That's an issue we don't know about on this side of the Whaleroad.I wonder if the change did not come about with the advent of Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, from Grantham. (East Midlands) Despite being from a shopkeeper's family, she had a shrill RP accent that now instantly raises the hackles of many Englishmen.