When do you get a soul? & related questions.

Discussion in 'Religion Archives' started by Dinosaur, May 31, 2009.

  1. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396
    -=-

    When have you seen me claim electrons exist?
    Turnabout is not fair play.
    The (main) reason people say you're full of shit is you won't offer anything substantial to support your claims.
     
  2. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  3. lightgigantic Banned Banned

    Messages:
    16,330
    It wasn't about souls.

    If you reread the posts you will see that stranger was just about to enlighten me as to how one can evidence something to the inimical




    whoa

    slow down cowboy

    we are just beginning at the point of theory here

    Please Register or Log in to view the hidden image!

     
  4. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  5. lightgigantic Banned Banned

    Messages:
    16,330
    :m:
     
  6. Google AdSense Guest Advertisement



    to hide all adverts.
  7. glaucon tending tangentially Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    5,502


    Ah.
    Well then, the thread has gone off topic.
    These posts should be deleted.



    Nonetheless, one cannot begin from nothing, which is what blind supposition is...
     
  8. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396

    Of course it is.



    Of course, I was not about to do such. I'm not so silly.



    I am open minded. You have no reason to think otherwise. I want all answers it is possible to have.



    We're not beginning anything. You're stuck in a rut. \
     
  9. SnakeLord snakeystew.com Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    5,758
    You said: "It appears we have to go back to issues of theory and determine what qualities determine a "soul"".

    So, let's go back to theory and determine what qualities 'determine' a soul. How do you propose it is 'determined'?

    Perhaps I use a different definition, but I consider 'determine' to mean: 'to conclude or ascertain, as after reasoning, observation, etc'.

    So, kindly show me - by going back to whatever 'theory' it is how you conclude or ascertain - after reasoning and observation - that a soul exists, what qualities that soul has and how we determine that to be the case. If you don't mind.
     
    Last edited: Jul 4, 2009
  10. Cris In search of Immortality Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,199
    lg,

    So your specific assertion that life is dependent on souls is valid because?
     
  11. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396

    Is that your evidence of souls?
     
  12. Cris In search of Immortality Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,199
    lg,

    You don't appear to have said anything of substance in that text.

    Soooo.. the theory is that life is dependent on souls? Correct? Or have I missed something? So now we have established the theory you'll now proceed to show the evidence, correct? I'm ready - please go ahead.
     
  13. Leo Volont Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    1,509
    Very few people understand what the Soul is.

    There really aren't individual souls.

    there is One Big Life Force. When a person achieves Spiritual Enlightenment, they realize their identity with this One Super Soul.

    yes, this Big Super Soul can be imprinted with small facets -- like a Big Jewel in the Sky. One atunes to it at different levels and vibrations. The Big Soul can behave anthropomorphically -- it can appear as deceased Saints or legendary Angels.

    To make the best sense out of it, I call it the Collective Consciousness. I can make the most use of it that way. Materialists acknowledge its importance and at the same time diminish it by calling it the Subconscious Mind.

     
  14. swarm Registered Senior Member

    Messages:
    4,207
    Yet somehow you are the exception?
     
  15. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396
    -=-

    Maybe he is.
    After pointing out this was going way off topic & resisting doing the same, I got caught up in it.
    Finally someone posted on topic. According to the OP, this thread wasn't meant to be about proof.
     
  16. Cris In search of Immortality Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,199
    The term "soul" as used in the OP assumes the concept of duality. I.e. a 1 to 1 relationship between a physical body and something imaterial that it depends upon somehow, e.g. a symbiotic relationship, or perhaps a dependent parasite.

    The idea is that this soul is the entity that represents the essense of "I" and is considered immortal. The question then becomes when do these two entities come together to make the whole.

    The Christians believe it occurs at conception and the Muslims believe it is some weeks later. Curiously this is why Bush tried to outlaw stemcell research and limit science while the perceived backwardness of Islam embraced such research.

    But before we can truly address the OP we need to understand what this "soul" thing is and how it relates to the physical. For example LG maintains that every living cell requires a "soul" to keep it alive. In which case a "soul" never enters a person but is an integral part of life, e.g. something alive cannot occur without this essential component.

    In Leo's case, soul is more like "The Force" in the Star Wars movies, and somehow our physical body's have some type of networking connection with this universal entity. The concept of a soul entering the body again makes no sense in this case.

    So once we have established the ideas the next step should be justifications and evidence, which is somewhat where we are in the topic.
     
  17. Cris In search of Immortality Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,199
    Somewhat returning to the OP again I question that the body has any need for a soul so the question of when has no relevance.

    The time of conception has a very basic problem, what happens when the embryo splits several days after conception and become two individuals? I.e. Identical twins. Does one have a soul a one does not? No one would accept that so conception is not the definitive moment.

    What about split brain scenarios where the connection between the two halves of the brain have been severed through either necessary surgery or injury? Studies here show two distinct personalities emerge in the same individual. Did a new soul appear or does one personality not have a soul, or does the soul split.

    All of these problems vanish once we realize that the physical body and personality have no dependence on imaterial souls. Psychologists have extensive case studies of personaility being dependent on brain health, genes, and function. A soul here provides nothing of value. In which case we should eliminate personality from the list of soul properties. The same can be said for memory. In which case if the dual concept of soul provides nothing in the way of personality or memory, then what does the soul do? Seemingly nothing.

    That brings us back to - what the heck is a soul and why is it needed?
     
  18. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396
    -=-

    I more wonder why the soul needs a body.
     
  19. Cris In search of Immortality Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    9,199
    This is a good point. The soul concept is based on ignorance of how consciousness is caused. If indeed a soul is the essence of consciousness and can exist externally to a body then why the heck would it ever need a body?

    Bear in mind that the soul idea by far pre-dates modern science and any notions of brain function or neural networks. If the ancients knew what we know now would the soul concept ever have arisen?
     
  20. SnakeLord snakeystew.com Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    5,758
    Of course not but we should also understand that the ancients didn't really mention 'souls' in the way that modern day theists do. As far as the bible goes, the words translated as 'soul' or 'spirit' all mean "breath" and merely represented a fact of life, (the living breathed and 'contained' breath, the dead did not). That modern day theists think it means invisible inner living you's is their own problem.
     
  21. (Q) Encephaloid Martini Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    20,855
    What I see from your post, Leo, is that you merely wish to place on a pedestal and over-dramatize the somewhat mundane. It may have appeared as something 'bigger-than-life' long ago, mysterious and mystical, but is simply the fundamental workings of the mind.

    In other words, you sound like the Sham-Wow guy trying to sell a piece of cloth.
     
  22. PsychoticEpisode It is very dry in here today Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    3,452
    Two reasons:

    One I think is more along the lines that it's a dead person that really needs a soul. Not too many cadavers have been seen ascending into heaven or descending into hell. Perhaps our ancestors also saw how much trouble making the connection from this world to the next was going to be for a carcass. There was a need to fill in a blank so to speak.

    The second reason is to make sure you get rewarded or punished for your time on Earth. However you would need reason one before two since it is tough to punish a corpse.

    The solution was to have everyone carry a soul around for a lifetime ensuring that the transitional phase takes place. It was simply logical to have a soul if one believed you lived forever in some other realm.

    The soul seems to have no other purpose than to act as the vehicle that transports your essence to another place. It's a freeloading consciousness that awakens and springs into action upon the death of the individual. :shrug:
     
  23. StrangerInAStrangeLand SubQuantum Mechanic Valued Senior Member

    Messages:
    15,396
    -=-

    Huh?
    Those are theories of why the body needs a soul.
    I was wondering the opposite. Why a soul needs a body.
     

Share This Page