Where is the poll?! People voted and became involved with one of the longest threads I have ever seen... this continuation is going nowhere with out...
The no-ships conceal a ship from prescience so it would be safe to say that an empath wouldn't have any luck. They don't give off any electromagnetic...
I thought phasers were nadion particles or something like that. There's more than one, they are the common mode of transportation from the...
Duncan Idaho uses the laser-shield interaction to setup minefields in Heretics of Dune. However, I think it relied on the enemy using Lazguns, which...
Dune has the element of surprise with their no-ships. Granted, ST has a decent response time due to transporter technology. I don't recall ST...
My understanding of Holtzman shielding is that it is based on the speed of the weapon being used. The problematic reaction of a Lazgun on the shield...
Dune doesn't have any transporters; they move by transport/shuttle. Lets clarify the issue of computers, while computers are forbidden they're...
Superior numbers and better ftl is a huge advantage that would give dune the win. Plus I think dune has better ground forces compared to either group.
It's been awhile, I thought I should bring Dune back into the argument. *Dune is multi-galactic in scope and far outnumbers ST or SW. *Dune has...
What does every one think of this as the Time and Setting for this debate: The proponents of each universe in contention should select the pinnacle...
Originally, I wanted to set down some agreed upon guidelines for the SW vs. ST thread. Hellblade8 wants to do a more encompassing guideline that can...
Actually, that is the OPer's choice whether to give one side an advantage. If you think that it is an unfair debate, then don't post in the thread...
We need more input from you guys! There have only been seven people, besides myself, giving suggestions. I know there are more of you out there and I...
Also, I think that simply having a stickied thread of fallacies would work better than an external link. This way its kept closer to the operations...
Oh, I agree it should be the OPer's choice on setting and the like. I was mainly focused on the SW vs. ST thread. Maybe we should have a...
6. Third party sites can be used but the burden of proof is not reliant on the site's credibility; instead, you are expected to understand the proof...
I believe there should be an agreed upon era for each universe. Everything vs Everything is a bit too messy. However, we could segment it into...
I PM'd Tristan about this idea, but we'll have to wait for a response. As of yet it would be an unofficial list of sci-debate criteria.
Shall we use the agenda I put forward?
A major issue to be addressed is time-travel. Should it only be allowed within the universes that have used it or should it bridge to other universes?
Separate names with a comma.
