These are all matters for the Debate itself (if it happens). They are inappropriate for the Proposal thread. These "gas claims" you intend to dispute are not clear, anyway. But that can also be dealt with in the Debate context. All we're doing here is determining (a) whether anybody will agree to debate your topic; and (b) if so, what the rules of the Debate will be. Nobody will attempt to establish anything here on the topic itself. You still seem to be confused about how this subforum operates. The rules are in a sticky thread on the forum topic list. Go and read them. We'll get to that if the debate ever gets off the ground.