so from one end you criticize expulsion of arabs but excuse that of jews-which you claim are only a religion. no im sorry, thats not convincing.
Brian foley you are a hypnotised drone of islam, you were dumped by a beutiful jewish or american lady at the alter get over it you bitch.
Given their history, you think they had no need? But let's compare points here: a handful of men (poorly) explode a bomb in a theatre and 25,000 Jews are kicked out - which you said didn't happen before. Does this really compare to the level of fighting in Palestine and Israel? You forget, perhaps, that it wasn't the Jews who started forcing people off their land? The Israelis were only following the Turkish and Palestinian model. http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/myths/mf2.html#b Hmm. No growth. Sort of puts some claims in perspective. Or, later, how about this? I wonder why they wouldn't serve on councils with Jews. Something about status in society, maybe? What now, then? Best regards, Geoff
they might have wanted it to be a need but there own country was not a need it was a want. They could have existed as a people without the creation israel. ps. on a side note if they wanted there own country shouldn't they have got in in an area were they were mearly looked down on and not an area where people might want to kill them.
Except that they keep getting exploited and killed when they live among the rest of us. Brilliant suggestion! Excellent suggestion! ...uhh...where would this be then? Cheers, Geoff
This is the kind of BS that Jinnah used to create Pakistan. Anyway, if it was so bad, they should all have moved to the secular west. The creation of a Jewish state in Palestine was unwarranted by any measure.
How is it BS? Can you demonstrate it didn't happen? I mean, sure: the large-scale deportation of Jewish people from Palestine really seems unlikely given that it would have occurred under the transitional government of the Ataturk party...I mean, if you ignore the deep and abiding concern for non-muslims that led to the whole Armenian Holocaust. Otherwise it's completely implausible. (** cough cough Kurds cough cough **) There's that "love it or leave it" argument again. And if they had no money to leave it, or no desire to abandon their ancestral home? Some people feel strongly about such things. How about Native Americans? I mean, if things were so bad here, maybe they just should have left. No? The creation of a Jewish state in Palestine was warranted by their numbers in the local population. In fact, if they made up about 11% or so of the population and were given about 10% of the land at partition...well, isn't that fair? Especially given the persecution they were suffering under at the time. Geoff
So then the Palestinians don't have no good reason to run the Jews out of Israel and replace Israel with another Arab State.
Except for all the illegal immigration. Unless you think the UN has a right to create a country for immigrants in anyone's land regardless of the opinion of the natives? Oh wait, thats how you formed your country, so of course you'll support it. Just murder and steal. And then act like you did them a big favor.
Buffalo Roam: "So then the Palestinians don't have no good reason to run the Jews out of Israel and replace Israel with another Arab State." pjdude: "you would have a point if not for the other reasons for Palestinian state hood" ... and if Jews could not be Arabs.