At the risk of getting my head bitten off may I suggest that Bells moderation was to point out that the thread has drifted off topic.
The traffic has dropped for this site.
Gentlemen is there anything we can do or should do is perhaps what should be the focus of discussion.
Alex
Bingo!
Has the traffic dropped for this site? Yes. It has and the reason I know it has is because over the better part of the last year or so, the staff had found ourselves in a situation where we were logging on to ban dozens of people an hour (my record was around 100+ pages of spam threads deleted and then moved in one sub-forum alone and I think it was over 60 spammers banned in one go and it took me about 2 hours to do and that was for just one sub-forum.. it took me several hours to clear the other equally spammed sub-forums, while trying to ban them as they were signing on at the same time). To wit, the numbers were so high at around this time last year, because we were getting in excess of a hundred new members a day, increasing site traffic and visitors, but these new members were spammers. Looking at other websites, who are seeing their number of visits shoot up, they also have severe spammer issues.
And we lost a lot of members during that period, simply because it had become nearly impossible to post at any given moment. Someone would start a thread and within about 30 seconds, that thread would be on the 30th page of the sub-forum it was posted on, simply because spammers would flood that sub-forum. We also lost some staff members from burn out because it had become absolutely insane.
Yes, we have lost actual members, but we have also gained new members. People come and go. We have all left for periods and then returned later. Real life, not being happy with the level of scientific discussion here at any given time, or dissatisfied with what people feel were the political leanings of those who post here (we have been accused of being leftist liberals by some and right wing fascists by others), to how we tolerate or do not tolerate people's personal beliefs, I could go on.. then returning and seeing how it is now going, rinse and repeat.
Do people want to see a jump by 34% to go back to last year's rate of visitors and new members? Sure, just remove the spam protection on this site. It will go up then, but you just won't be able to post anything in the sea of spam that will infest this site. I mean, if we are looking at just the numbers, that is your solution.
There is this expectation that we have to please everyone. We cannot. That would be an impossible task. What we can do is try and have an expectation for how people post, what they post and where and try and get people to be able to support their arguments. There are a variety of different subjects being discussed on this site, in the hope that there is something for everyone, and also in the hope of trying to keep the woo out of the science sub-forums and we also try to instill the need for supporting one's arguments throughout this forum. We are all individuals, with different opinions, beliefs, experiences, education, culture. We cannot please everyone. But we can expect that others post in good faith and be able to argue their points in good faith and be able to support their arguments or claims..