I like you to have another look at this question:
http://www.animations.physics.unsw.edu.au/jw/rolling.htm
Yes it is my contention, that seen from fixed points in line with the sun , watching a laser shining out from the equators of Saturn, Jupiter , the beam would linger in the noon position, but measure to move at ~ twice the orbital speed during the the midnight phase.
To see the equivalent situation demonstrated in the NSW university videos, imagine the driving wheel carrying a laser shining on the floor and the ceiling during a rotation. The spot will come to a halt on the floor, but hurry along at twice the speed on the ceiling.
Saturn, Jupiters equators move like that.
Am I reading this correctly?
Is it your contention that for a rotating sphere, one side of the sphere rotates at twice the speed as the other side?
If that is truly your contention ----?
No I am not saying that, but if you look at it from the field of the sun "fixed" rather than from satellites moving moving with the planet. yes I am saying that for Saturn and Jupiter. To see why, please watch the animations in the videos below:Let's try a thought experiment imagine a satellite that stays in orbit directly between the Sun and Jupiter, plus another satellite that stays in orbit on the other side of Jupiter in a line with the sun and Jupiter. Hopefully that makes sense, 2 satellites on opposite sides of Jupiter on a line drawn through Jupiter from the sun that remain in that position as Jupiter orbits the Sun. Lets put a beacon on Jupiter that rotates with Jupiter.
If we measured the speed of the beacon as it revolves around Jupiter, is it your contention that we would measure a speed that was twice as fast on the night side as the day side? Do you see a problem with this?
http://www.animations.physics.unsw.edu.au/jw/rolling.htm
Yes it is my contention, that seen from fixed points in line with the sun , watching a laser shining out from the equators of Saturn, Jupiter , the beam would linger in the noon position, but measure to move at ~ twice the orbital speed during the the midnight phase.
To see the equivalent situation demonstrated in the NSW university videos, imagine the driving wheel carrying a laser shining on the floor and the ceiling during a rotation. The spot will come to a halt on the floor, but hurry along at twice the speed on the ceiling.
Saturn, Jupiters equators move like that.