Steven Crothers , against BB

https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Stephen_J._Crothers

Stephen Crothers is a handyman/ gardener who has never published a legitimate peer reviewed paper.

and the insults and the lot , are no surprise to me , he is going against the main after all and ;

what has publishing a paper have anything to do with his presentations ?

and even if he did try to get any paper published , it probably never would be . going against the black-hole and relativity , " crowd ".

there are other videos of him . getting into deeper mathematics , by the way .
 
found on Youtube

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=stephen crothers destroys the Quackademic " Black Hole " & Relativity

He is an astronomer and mathematician who does research into relativity .

Hi River.
Thanks for thinking your link may be of interest to the forum.

May I suggest that given the utube presentation is recognisably anti mainstream that in the future you post similar stuff somewhere in the fringe.
You only burden a mod with the task of moving it and also most likely to upset members because you are posting fringe stuff in the science section.
You doing so is somewhat confrontational and really not in keeping with what the science section is about I feel.

I am not being unkind.

This site gives a little bit of room to consider outside mainstream but posting in this manner can only cause a response that your sort of posting not have even a home in the fringe part of here at all...your type of action here hands nails out for the coffin for the fringe.


Anyways nice to see you here and I hope you are well.
Alex
 
Last edited:
and the insults and the lot , are no surprise to me , he is going against the main after all and ;

what has publishing a paper have anything to do with his presentations ?

and even if he did try to get any paper published , it probably never would be . going against the black-hole and relativity , " crowd ".

there are other videos of him . getting into deeper mathematics , by the way .
Whatever.
 
oh it's science alright , just science that the main don't like .

one wonders what the motivation was to attack Steven in the first place .

to here him out is science . to discount him because of someone elses opinion of him is not science . think for your self .

I have thought for myself... and what he said made absolutely no sense in context with the greater body of knowledge that we have already accumulated.

That, and if he actually had a case for this, and could prove something as huge as "oh, wait, black holes don't actually exist", he'd be a nobel prize winner in an instant.

Simply put - the evidence is not in his corner.
 
I have thought for myself... and what he said made absolutely no sense in context with the greater body of knowledge that we have already accumulated.

That, and if he actually had a case for this, and could prove something as huge as "oh, wait, black holes don't actually exist", he'd be a nobel prize winner in an instant.

Simply put - the evidence is not in his corner.
I hear he's a good gardener though.
 
He is a Queenslander... He lost all credibility right there.

Its a pity he does not post here as I am sure he and paddoboy could have some interesting chats...that is if paddoboy could overlook that he is a Queenslander.

Alex
 
Has anybody actually watched Steven's video ?

Until then , your comments don't mean much .

And if you have , e-mail him your concerns . Nothing like a conversation with him , to clear up any concerns you have .
 
Has anybody actually watched Steven's video ?
I watched it.
The first time it started and I saw Electric Universe so I stopped it.
But then I thought that was not giving it a fair go and seeing it was you who suggested looking I did.

I may even look again.

But yes I have seen it.

What part did you particularly like?
Do you agree or disagree with what he says.

Alex
 
Back
Top