# Tunnels Reverse Global Warming And Weaken Hurricanes

Discussion in 'Earth Science' started by cat2only, Sep 17, 2007.

1. ### spidergoatLiddle' Dick TaterValued Senior Member

Messages:
53,883
The ice is melting due to increased air temperatures, which would not be affected by this scheme.

3. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
Thats exactly what the tunnels do is lower air temps. by displacing most all the fossil fuels along with upwelling cooler waters from the oceans depths.

5. ### spidergoatLiddle' Dick TaterValued Senior Member

Messages:
53,883
Even if it worked, it could only supply power to a small part of the world.

7. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
You sure about that here is an example:

Enough to supply the USA with electrical power many times over! ~ 3.050 Million Megawatts!

Since you need volume to get your answer, I made the assumption that the water is also 100 ft long. Kinetic Energy equals (1/2)m*v^2 so we got .5*299,025,900,000kg*(8.941 m/s)^2 = 149,512,950,000kg*79.941(m^2/s^2) = 11,952,214,735,950 joules.

BTW, thats for the entire 100 ft. So over the 100 ft, your 100 ft tall and 20 mile wide wall of water exerts nearly 12 trillion joules. If you want watts find out how long it took to go that 100 ft in seconds and divide the joules by that time. Then you have joules/second which equals watts. And watts can easily be converted into mega watts.

Last edited: Sep 26, 2007
8. ### spidergoatLiddle' Dick TaterValued Senior Member

Messages:
53,883
I don't mean the power output, but the ability to distribute it.

9. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
BTW thats per hour.

10. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
Transmission infrastructure is already here all we have to do is tie into it.

Messages:
10,296
Ha! Nice try - but it's not going to work! I never asked you about Pascal and you know it - now answer the questions I put to you directly and forget the childish attemtp to sidestep.:bugeye:

12. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
I can't explain it any better than Pascal does.Sorry.

Messages:
10,296
You are being silly and obstinate - you know very well what questions I mean. Do you want me to embarrass you by posting them in the wide open again for everyone else to see? They show you to be very foolish - but I will if you try to avoid them just one more time.

14. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334

Pascal says any pressure differential within an enclosed system where energy is conserved a flow will occur!

I can't explain that any better can you?

Messages:
10,296
OK, I was very kind and generous and gave you SEVERAL chances to respond. Since you choose instead to try and act dumb about it, I'll list them out for you (and everyone else) to show the inconsistencies of claims you've made. Ready? Here they come:

1. In one post you say this: "I need to find some fine university to computer model this for me.
I also know it is not a silly idea due to the fact Pascal's principle and Bernoulli principles work very well in this case. Any of you fine people here know of a University that may be interested?"

Yet in another post you say about your friend in Florida: "His excuse was NOAA is not funded for it even though he did it, anyways."

So which is it? It's been modeled or not? You've clearly said both.

2. About the coral reef decline. In one post, you included a quote which listed the causes of that:
"increased water temperatures (often attributed to global warming[1])
starvation caused by a decline in zooplankton levels as a result of overfishing.[2]
changes in water chemistry
silt runoff
pathogen infections "

And when I pointed out that increased temperature was only ONE of the causes and reducing that would do nothing about the others, you responded with your childish name-calling post: "Yea #1 on the list you trolling idiot! Now get off my post and learn not to Read-Only TRY TO COMPREHEND FOR ONCE IN YOUR LIFE!"

But you never answered the question at all. Do so now!

There are others that I will get to later but let's see you answer these first before moving along.

Last edited: Sep 26, 2007
16. ### Captain KremmenAll aboard, me Hearties!Valued Senior Member

Messages:
12,738
Said Gandalf.

17. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
From a person at HRD.

1.) > > Unfortunately there is a dearth of models capable of testing
> such a
> > hypothesis. The operational models are coupled to the ocean in
> a 1-D
> > sense eliminating any advection in the ocean. Research models
> are coming
> > along that could be used to look at 3-D interactions, but they
> are so
> > new I am not sure that you could be sure the results was caused
> by the
> > changes you induce or by other issues the new models have not been
> > tested for yet. The big challenge is the ocean modeling (there
> are some
> > good research ocean models, but the issue of forcing in a
> hurricane > environment is not completely understood yet - spray,
> wave breaking,
> > etc), and then the coupling of it to the atmosphere to get the
> > appropriate feedback. We are working on that for the next
> generation > operational models, but it still a work in progress.
> I think in a few
> > years we may have such a tool ready to test your idea in a
> credible
> > manner.

So it seems as though they don't have a program to model it yet. That other person was the former director of HRD who did some calculations for me.

2.) The #1 reason for the corals decline is the warmer SSTs which the Tunnels can cool back off due to the massive upwelling they cause.The warmer temps can also cause more Pathogens that destroy the corals which the Tunnels can also prevent.They also can prevent the red tide.

18. ### Captain KremmenAll aboard, me Hearties!Valued Senior Member

Messages:
12,738
Cat2
Glad to see you are holding your own against the bullying and patronising you are being subjected to. I just hope that you stay with us and are not tempted to move somewhere else. You clearly have a good mind and are not a loony. Though if you have a good mind and are also a loony you are also welcome as far as I am concerned.

btw
Do you think that these pipelines are:
i A future source for energy
ii A solution for the Global Warming problem

19. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
Thanks for the kind words Cris Cremin. I'll let Pascal and Bernoulli do the work for me.The same principles that make airplanes fly will also make the tunnels work.

i A future source for energy ? YES
ii A solution for the Global Warming problem? YES and so much more.

20. ### matthyaouwRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
162

Messages:
10,296
Sure sounds like it.

And that idea would be WAY more practical than trying to build all those silly tunnels that can't do much anyway. And I have to agree with what was also said in the article - that there may be serious consequences to trying something like that.

22. ### spidergoatLiddle' Dick TaterValued Senior Member

Messages:
53,883
It doesn't sound so weird when they say it, but it's one of those ideas like a space elevator, or Freeman Dyson's nuclear bomb-powered spaceship- impractical and probably never going to happen. Still, like Chris said, I do appreciate your ideas, cat2only. I might be critical of them, but nothing personal.

23. ### cat2onlyRegistered Senior Member

Messages:
334
Now that is a neat idea, also. However, it is different than my idea. This idea doesn't use the Gulfsteam current to upwell the water is uses the wave action with a check valve in line.
The tunnels generate an enormous amount of electrical power while these pipelines don't. They do nothing to offset the fossil fuels we are already burning. They are not deep enough to tap into the cooler waters at depth. They would have to be at least 1000 feet or so. Remember, the fuel for any hurricane is the 300-400 foot warm thermal surface layer which may only change by two or three degrees.They would have to change SSTs by about 4 degrees in the Gulfstream to restore the Arctic Ice.They do not work at all when the ocean is calm unlike my tunnels do which can work 24/7 if needed.