Kadark,
I simply do not think you are not thinking clearly.
Before the Spanish went to war with the Aztecs there were many wars between South Americans and so we can justify killing and stealing …
Before the Europeans went to war with the Native Americans there were many wars between the Native Tribes and so we can justify war of aggression…
Before the Americans went to war against Iraq there were many things Saddam did that GW Bush Jr didn’t like… and so we can justify war with Iraq…
Makes as much sense to me.
War of aggression is wrong.
Did you miss that?
That’s what I am referring to.
OK, look at it this way, do you think that the Greeks made their advancements BECAUSE they were polytheists?
Do you think Newton discovered calculus BECAUSE he was Christian?
Do you think Einstein discovered e=mc^2 BECAUSE he was Atheist?
Well, do you?
Nope
Timeline of the history of scientific method
Yes Muslim philosophers did add to the advancing of science – BUT I also feel they could have done much much more. The reason why I think so is because, when I compare their advancements to that of ancient Greeks/Romans and with the Europeans post-Renaissance it’s plain to see they were being held back.
Do you know what Alhazen did for a living before he wrote his book on optics? Did you know he spent a lot of time in prison and died there? Do you know why? What was the date and when was the Golden Age of “Islam”? When did he die? Why again? Something you may want to think about as you ponder poor Alhazen’s death in custody. Soon you may even come to the conclusion “Islam” had nothing to do with Alhazen’s work and probably he was greatly influenced by his earlier work as a transcriber. Why did he die again? What was so Golden about this Age? Oh yeah, “Islam”.
I usually think of Francis Bacon when I think of the Scientific Method.
The greatest math principal discovered.
An example of the human form in sculpture and bronze (a pic is fine).
An example of an “Islamic” monument (a pic of a period building).
The greatest discovery in biology.
A period peace of the greatest painter (a pic of a painting).
The principal treaty on Civic rights and Democracy (title is fine)
Should be a snap really and I’d really like to see them. and I'd think you'd be happy to post them anyway.
The method of exhaustion (calculus) was rediscovered in China by Liu Hui in the 3rd century AD, who used it to find the area of a circle. It was also used by Zu Chongzhi in the 5th century AD, who used it to find the volume of a sphere.
Gee must be due to Taoism – right Kadark?
Come on, you are being biased, and it influences even the way you are reading my posts and debating the points, you'll certainly not find me saying modern physics came from Christianity and you'd agree, but here you are saying the same thing about calculus and Islam :bugeye: THAT'S Biasedness.
Michael
I simply do not think you are not thinking clearly.
Before the Mongolians went to war with China there were many wars between Chinese and so we can justify killing them and stealing their land and looting their stuff…There was. Before the Caliphate, the middle east was full of different tribesmen and Persians who went to war with Byzantians, who went to war with barbarians, etc. It was an endless cycle of war and uneasiness.
Before the Spanish went to war with the Aztecs there were many wars between South Americans and so we can justify killing and stealing …
Before the Europeans went to war with the Native Americans there were many wars between the Native Tribes and so we can justify war of aggression…
Before the Americans went to war against Iraq there were many things Saddam did that GW Bush Jr didn’t like… and so we can justify war with Iraq…
Makes as much sense to me.
War of aggression is wrong.
You are not thinking clearly. I am not singleing Islam out. Any Religion. As a matter of fact Norsefire said as much and I agreed.Hindered? I see no point in debating you, man. Are you f^ing serious? HINDERED? Science was hindered by Islam?
Did you miss that?
That’s what I am referring to.
And this has what to do with “Islam”? Absolutely Nothing.modern science to have begun in the Islamic civilization, in particular, due to the beginning of the modern scientific method among Muslim scientists.
OK, look at it this way, do you think that the Greeks made their advancements BECAUSE they were polytheists?
Do you think Newton discovered calculus BECAUSE he was Christian?
Do you think Einstein discovered e=mc^2 BECAUSE he was Atheist?
Well, do you?
Nope
Timeline of the history of scientific method
Yes Muslim philosophers did add to the advancing of science – BUT I also feel they could have done much much more. The reason why I think so is because, when I compare their advancements to that of ancient Greeks/Romans and with the Europeans post-Renaissance it’s plain to see they were being held back.
Do you know what Alhazen did for a living before he wrote his book on optics? Did you know he spent a lot of time in prison and died there? Do you know why? What was the date and when was the Golden Age of “Islam”? When did he die? Why again? Something you may want to think about as you ponder poor Alhazen’s death in custody. Soon you may even come to the conclusion “Islam” had nothing to do with Alhazen’s work and probably he was greatly influenced by his earlier work as a transcriber. Why did he die again? What was so Golden about this Age? Oh yeah, “Islam”.
I usually think of Francis Bacon when I think of the Scientific Method.
Can you give me a specific list of your favortes:They surpassed them because of their scientific methods with experimenting.
The greatest math principal discovered.
An example of the human form in sculpture and bronze (a pic is fine).
An example of an “Islamic” monument (a pic of a period building).
The greatest discovery in biology.
A period peace of the greatest painter (a pic of a painting).
The principal treaty on Civic rights and Democracy (title is fine)
Should be a snap really and I’d really like to see them. and I'd think you'd be happy to post them anyway.
I’m asking you to pick one. Then tell me why this has anything to do with “Islam”.The best piece of Islamic mathematics? Take your pick. Algebra, arithmetic, calculus, cryptography, geometry, induction, number theory, trigonometry...
The method of exhaustion (calculus) was rediscovered in China by Liu Hui in the 3rd century AD, who used it to find the area of a circle. It was also used by Zu Chongzhi in the 5th century AD, who used it to find the volume of a sphere.
Gee must be due to Taoism – right Kadark?
Come on, you are being biased, and it influences even the way you are reading my posts and debating the points, you'll certainly not find me saying modern physics came from Christianity and you'd agree, but here you are saying the same thing about calculus and Islam :bugeye: THAT'S Biasedness.
Michael
Last edited: