BlueSky
Registered Senior Member
Perhaps. Or perhaps he was never dead to begin with; medical science wasn't really up to determining whether someone in hypovolemic shock was dead or not back then. If he wasn't breathing and had no (detectable) heartbeat that was it; off to the tomb (or grave.)
Fun fact - as recently as the 1700's, people demanded to be buried in "safety coffins" because occasionally someone would "die" have a funeral, be buried - and then recover and find themselves six feet under in a coffin. The safety coffin had a chain you could pull to ring a bell by your gravestone, and you would then be dug up before you suffocated. So even with a higher level of medical science, people were sometimes found alive after being thought dead for days.
I can meet you there. However, the Romans were not usually the kind of people to let someone live after a Crucifixion. If we can trust the bible he had a spear thrust into his side and water came out, a sign of death. His bones were not broken ( as per prophecy in the OT of what would happen to the Messiah. ) because they saw he was dead.
To think one could have all that done to them and then sit in a cold tomb for 3 days without treatment is streatching it imo.. doubting Thomas put his hand in the wound on his side also. Plus the whipping and nails in hands a feet’s. I don’t know about you, but I am not surviving that.