I disagree. I reiterate that moderation should address what is, not what might be. We are a science forum, not fantasy forums.
I repeat: the thread was closed because of your opening post, not for any other reson. That is what was, not what might have been.
Also perhaps in light of your extensive experience, could you explain why you did not "nip in the bud" the Muslims lie thread?
Probably didn't see it. Did I post in it? Probably didn't receive any complaints about it, either.